讲座：The Positive and Negative Effects of Social Status on Ratings of Voice Behavior: A Test of Opposing Structural and Psychological Pathways
题 目：The Positive and Negative Effects of Social Status on Ratings of Voice Behavior: A Test of Opposing Structural and Psychological Pathways
嘉 宾：Sijun Kim, Ph.D. Candidate at the Eller College of Management, the University of Arizona
主持人：李欣欣 助理教授 上海交通大学安泰经济与管理学院
时 间：2020年09月23日（周三） 10:30-12:00
地 点：线上ZOOM平台 (校内师生如需获取会议号和密码，请于9月22日中午12点前发送电邮至orgmgt@acem.sjtu.edu.cn)
We examine how social status—the amount of respect and admiration conferred by others—is related to leader’s ratings of team member voice. In a field study using 375 West Point cadets nested in 60 squads, we find that that there are two countervailing pathways linking social status to leader voice ratings: a positive structural path via instrumental network centrality and a negative psychological path via perceived image risk. In addition, we show that these relationships are contingent upon a relational moderator, such that high-quality team interpersonal relationships weakened the positive indirect effect via instrumental network centrality but strengthened the negative indirect effect via image risk. Two post hoc experiments provided preliminary support for our arguments that perceived image risk causes people to develop and deliver their voice in a manner that is more acceptable to recipients and ruled out several alternative explanations. In contrast to its impact on leader’s ratings of voice, we found a different pattern of results for team member’s ratings of voice: notably, the indirect effect via image risk was positive, rather than negative. The results of our multi-level analyses shed new light on how, why, and when social status impacts leader ratings of voice. In doing so, we challenge assumptions about voice behavior and open avenues for future research.
Sijun Kim is a doctoral candidate at the Eller College of Management, the University of Arizona. His research interests are primarily about voice and status with a focus on antecedents and consequences of voice and psychological experiences of status. His work has been presented at multiple academic conferences including the Academy of Management Annual Meeting and the Annual Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology Conference. Currently, he has multiple manuscripts with requested revisions at the Academy of Management Journal and the Journal of Applied Psychology. At Eller, he has been awarded the Stephen Robbins Doctoral Fellowship twice, the Outstanding Graduate Student Teaching Award, and the AKMS-Samsung Economic Research Institute Scholarship for Best Student Conference Papers. Additionally, he has experience teaching both in-person and online. Before joining Eller, He received a B.B.A. and an M.S. in Management, both from Korea University and has two-year work experience in the HR department of a South Korean company, POSCO Daewoo, which is now POSCO International.